| Athlete | Class of | College Team |
| Jillan Soder | 2024 | Penn State Behrend |
| Ella Garrity | 2024 | Penn State Behrend |
| Olivia Kulyk | 2024 | NJIT |
| Anna Tranum | 2021 | Amherst College |
| Kayla Sharman | 2021 | St.Vincent College |
| Riley Childress | 2021 | Roberts Wesleyan College |
| Joce Ollinger | 2021 | St. Lawrence University |
| Kelly Benson | 2020 | St.Vincent College |
| Emily Hess | 2020 | Westminster College |
| Torsha McCall | 2020 | Edinboro University |
| Jillian Spano | 2019 | Mercyhurst University |
| Carly Lazar | 2019 | Carlow University |
| Sierra Seneta | 2019 | Point Park University |
| Ali Benim | 2019 | Gannon |
| Margo Loutzenhiser | 2019 | Gannon |
| Emma McDermott | 2019 | Mercyhurst |
| Addy Cross | 2019 | Holy Cross |
| Abby Chermack | 2018 | Penn State – Behrend |
| Monica Brown | 2018 | Edinboro |
| Emily Bauer | 2018 | Mercyhurst University |
| Madison Demski | 2018 | Holy Cross |
| Sydney Palermo | 2018 | Bowling Green |
| Molly Mraz | 2018 | Richmond |
| Emily Shopene | 2017 | Mercyhurst University |
| Sarah Agnello | 2016 | Lafayette College |
| Anna Sweny | 2016 | Canisius College |
| Jennifer Oduho | 2016 | Youngstown State |
| Jaclyn Kitts | 2016 | West Liberty University |
| DJ Hahn | 2016 | California Univ of PA |
| Lauren Davenport | 2016 | University of Mt. Union |
| Emily Fromknecht | 2016 | Westminster College |
| Maria Welch | 2015 | Canisius College |
| Emily Stoicovy | 2015 | Nova Southeastern University |
| Nicole Maxson | 2015 | Clarion University |
| Allison Thompson | 2015 | Edinboro University |
| Deja Young | 2015 | Lock Haven University |
| Madi Steiner | 2015 | John Carroll University |
| Amesha Harden-Pullium | 2014 | Clarion University |
| Lindsey Mifsud | 2014 | Seton Hill University |
| Erika Woll | 2014 | Penn State – Behrend |
| Nikki Arbanas | 2014 | Youngstown State University |
| Angelina Starr | 2014 | Belmont Abbey |
| Alex Artise | 2013 | Mercyhurst University |
| Brenna Robbins | 2013 | Longwood University |
| Karlee McBride | 2013 | Indiana University |
| Sarah Graham | 2012 | Penn State – Behrend |
| Amanda Berchtold | 2012 | Gannon University |
| Zhane Brooks | 2012 | Indiana University of Pennsylvania |
| Kaitlyn Fromknecht | 2012 | Allegheny College |
| Leah Hansen | 2012 | University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown |
| Adrienne Kloecker | 2012 | Mercyhurst University |
| Taylor Lindquist | 2012 | Denison University |
| Lisa Mifsud | 2012 | College of the Holy Cross |
| Abbey Steudler | 2012 | St. Leo University |
| Brooklyn Taylor | 2012 | St. Francis University (PA) |
| Kayla Wilwohl | 2012 | Allegheny College |
| Emily Greer | 2011 | Le Moyne College |
| Maddie Hahesy | 2011 | Le Moyne College |
| Valerie Majewski | 2011 | University at Buffalo |
| Lindsay Stamp | 2011 | Indiana University of Pennsylvania |
| Ally Burke | 2011 | Penn State – Behrend |
| Chandler Moore | 2011 | University Of Mt. Union |
| Autumn Anderson | 2010 | Kenyon College |
| Adele Campbell | 2010 | Mercyhurst College |
| Kayla McBride | 2010 | University of Notre Dame |
| Ashley Prischak | 2010 | Le Moyne College |
| Cara Wyant | 2010 | Haverford College |
| Jess Zoltowski | 2010 | Elmira College |
| Tenesha Aden | Penn State - Behrend | |
| Meagan Bielanin | Penn State - Behrend | |
| Allison Braun | Canisius | |
| Courtney Bricher | Penn State - Behrend | |
| Amy Butler | Mercyhurst | |
| Amanda Byers | Mercyhurst - North East | |
| Amanda Chojnacki | Slippery Rock | |
| Rachel Dillon | Waynesburg | |
| Nicolle Di Raimo | Florida Southern College | |
| Kristen Fournier | West Virginia Wesleyan | |
| Katie Fuhrmann | Carlow College | |
| Chelsea Gordon | Illinois | |
| Sarah Grab | West Virginia Wesleyan | |
| Hillary Hager | Vanderbilt | |
| Sarah Hansen | Florida Gulf Coast | |
| Tori Hansen | West Liberty | |
| Casey Heller | Edinboro | |
| Megan Hoffman | Mercyhurst | |
| Vickie Innes | Penn State - Behrend | |
| Erin Kerner | Quinnipiac | |
| Beth Kraus | Gannon | |
| Ann Mimm | Niagara | |
| Raegan Moore | Duquesne | |
| Carrie Nolan | Gannon | |
| Kelly Nowacinski | Penn State - Behrend | |
| Amy Oldach | Penn State - Behrend | |
| Kirsten Olowinski | Miami (Ohio) | |
| Beth Van Parys | Allegheny | |
| Stephanie Prischak | Mercyhurst | |
| Allison Roberts | Allegheny | |
| Nicole Ross | Gannon | |
| Julie Sedler | Penn State - Behrend | |
| Cassie Seth | Mercyhurst | |
| Kristen Sienicki | Penn State - Behrend | |
| Courtney Thompson | Edinboro | |
| Nicole Pacinelli Nies | Penn State - Behrend | |
| Maria Di Vecchio | Edinboro | |
| Allisyn Williams | Illinois Tech | |
| Mashea Williams | Penn State | |
| Brittany Wilwohl | Siena |